Short answer: collect emails on your own website, with a signup box on every page and a simple reason to join (new pieces, restocks, early access). Add your site address to packaging inserts and social profiles. Don't add Etsy buyers to your list from their order emails: Etsy's rules require their consent. Then send a short, useful email about once a month, linking straight to your Etsy listings.
Why it's worth it
Your email list is the one audience Etsy can't change. When search rankings drop, an email can still bring people to your shop that day. Sellers use their lists for:
- New collections and restocks
- Holiday order deadlines
- Craft fair and market dates
- A thank-you discount for returning customers
A small list of people who chose to hear from you is worth more than a big list of people who didn't.
What Etsy allows
Etsy buyers give you their email to complete an order, not to receive marketing. Etsy's policies don't allow adding them to a mailing list without their permission. Respect that, and build the list from people who sign up themselves.
Where to collect emails
| Place | How |
|---|---|
| Your website | A signup box on every page and at the end of every post |
| Packaging | A card with your site address and a line like "Join for first look at new pieces" |
| Instagram, TikTok, Pinterest bios | A link to your site's signup |
| Markets and fairs | A QR code to your site, or a paper signup sheet |
| Etsy shop announcement | A mention of your website (without asking for emails inside Etsy) |
Your site is the anchor. Every other place points there.
Give people a reason
"Subscribe to our newsletter" rarely works. Tell people what they'll get:
- "New pieces first, about once a month."
- "Restock alerts for sold-out designs."
- "Care tips and the story behind each collection."
What to send
Keep it short. One email a month with:
- One new piece or collection with a photo and a link to the Etsy listing.
- One useful thing: a care tip, a styling idea, a gift guide link.
- A personal line about what's happening in your studio.
Before big gift dates, send one extra email with your order deadline.
Which email tool
Most sellers use a dedicated email tool: Mailchimp, Kit (formerly ConvertKit), MailerLite and others all have plans for small lists. Check each one's current pricing page; free plan limits change. What matters is that it handles unsubscribes and includes your address in every email, which they all do.
Using Makerloom for your list
Every Makerloom site has a signup box on every page. Subscribers show up in your dashboard with the post they joined from, so you can see which topics attract people. Download the list as a CSV any time and import it into your email tool. See Subscribers.
How fast lists grow
Expect a few signups per hundred visitors to start. The list grows as your site gets more visitors, which is why helpful posts and an email list work well together: posts bring people in, the list keeps them.
A simple first email
If you've never emailed your list, start with this shape:
- Subject: what's new, plainly. "Three new speckled mugs, and a restock."
- One photo of the new piece.
- Two or three sentences about it: what inspired it, how it's made.
- One button to the Etsy listing.
- One line about what's coming next.
That's it. Short emails with one clear thing to look at get the most clicks.
Common mistakes
- Waiting until the list is big. Start emailing at 20 subscribers; habits matter more than size.
- Only emailing when there's a sale. People stop opening emails that are always discounts.
- Forgetting mobile. Most people read on phones, so use one column and big buttons.
Common questions
How often should I email?
Once a month is a good default. More often before big gift dates is fine if each email has something new.
Do I need double opt-in?
Not required in the US, but many tools offer it and it keeps the list clean. In some countries, like Germany, it's expected.
Should I offer a discount for signing up?
It works, but it trains people to wait for codes. A first look at new work is often enough for handmade buyers.
