Makerloom vs Etsy Offsite Ads

Updated November 2026

Short answer: Offsite Ads are Etsy's paid ads on Google, social media and other sites. You pay nothing up front, but Etsy takes 15% of each sale they bring (12% once your shop has made $10,000 in a year, when they also become mandatory), capped at $100 an order. Makerloom is a flat monthly price for your own site and posts that bring shoppers from Google and AI answers to your listings, with no fee per sale. Shoppers who arrive from your Makerloom site don't trigger the Offsite Ads fee unless they also clicked an Etsy ad within 30 days.

At a glance

Makerloom Etsy Offsite Ads
Cost $19, $39 or $79 a month 15% or 12% of each attributed order, up to $100
Cost on 20 sales of $45 $19 to $79 for the month $135 at 15%
You choose what's shown Yes, you approve each post No, Etsy chooses listings and placements
Builds something you keep Yes, pages and an email list No
Can opt out Cancel anytime Only under $10,000 a year
See where buyers came from Visits by source, per post Fees per order in your payment account

Where Makerloom is stronger

The cost doesn't grow with your sales. With Offsite Ads, your best month is your most expensive. With Makerloom, it's the same price whether your posts send 10 shoppers or 1,000.

It compounds. An ad stops when the campaign moves on. A helpful post can keep bringing shoppers from Google and AI answers for years.

You choose the message. Posts show your products in context: why this necklace suits sensitive ears, which mug keeps coffee hot. Ads show a thumbnail.

You keep the relationship. Visitors to your site can join your email list. Ad clicks go straight into Etsy.

The numbers on a real month

A shop under $10,000 a year, $45 average order:

Attributed sales Offsite Ads fee (15%) Makerloom Starter
5 $33.75 $19
20 $135.00 $19
50 $337.50 $19

Makerloom doesn't replace Etsy's normal fees (listing, 6.5% transaction, payment processing), which apply to every Etsy sale. See How much does Etsy take per sale?.

Using both

Many shops can't opt out of Offsite Ads (above $10,000 a year). That's fine: Makerloom adds a second source of shoppers alongside them. For shops under $10,000, a common pattern is to build up traffic with Makerloom, then decide whether to opt out based on what the numbers show. See Etsy Offsite Ads fees explained.

How each one reaches shoppers

Offsite Ads place your listings in ad slots on Google Shopping, social feeds and partner sites. Etsy chooses the listings, the placements and the wording. The shopper sees a thumbnail and a price, taps, and lands on your listing.

Makerloom publishes pages on your own site that answer a question, like "gold filled vs gold plated", with your products shown where they fit. Shoppers find those pages through regular Google results and AI answers, read the explanation, then tap through to the listing that suits them. They arrive already knowing why that piece is right.

What you can see

Offsite Ads Makerloom
Which listings were shown Not shown to sellers You approved every post
Where visitors came from Not broken down Google, Bing, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot, Claude, social
Which page sent them to Etsy No Per post, in Traffic
Sales Orders marked as Offsite Ads, with the fee Clicks to Etsy (sales stay in Etsy)

A simple way to decide

If you're under $10,000 a year, look at three months of Offsite Ads fees in your payment account and compare them with Makerloom's monthly price. If the fees are higher and you want something that keeps working, try Makerloom for a few months before opting out, so you have a second source in place first.

Common questions

Will Makerloom shoppers ever be charged the Offsite Ads fee?

Only if the same buyer clicked an Etsy Offsite Ad in the 30 days before buying. Etsy decides attribution.

Is Makerloom an ad?

No. Makerloom publishes pages on your own site. Shoppers find them through regular search and AI answers, not paid placements.

Sources

  • Etsy Help: How Offsite Ads work (help.etsy.com/hc/articles/360000338367), checked November 2026

Get shoppers to your Etsy listings from Google and AI answers.

Try Makerloom free

Prices and features of other products were checked on their own websites on the date above and can change. Makerloom isn't affiliated with the companies mentioned on this page.

More compare