Makerloom vs Shopify for Etsy sellers

Updated November 2026

Short answer: Shopify is a complete store: your own checkout, payments and apps, from $39 a month ($29 billed yearly) plus card fees, and every visitor is yours to find. Makerloom is built for Etsy sellers who want more shoppers without moving their store: it creates a site and writes helpful posts from your Etsy products so people find you on Google and in AI answers, then buy on Etsy. Most Etsy sellers looking for traffic, not a second store to run, are better served by Makerloom.

At a glance

Makerloom Shopify
Price Free to start, then $19, $39 or $79 a month Basic $39 a month, or $29 billed yearly
Card fees None (buyers pay on Etsy) 2.9% + 30¢ online on Basic with Shopify Payments
Setup time About 10 minutes Hours to days: theme, products, payments, shipping, policies
Products Synced from Etsy Imported or added; Etsy sync needs an app
Writes posts that bring shoppers Yes, 8 to 40 a month No, you write your own blog
Checkout, reviews, buyer protection Etsy's Your own, built from scratch
AI visits shown Yes Not by default
You run Nothing new A second store: orders, payments, customer service

Where Makerloom is stronger

Traffic is the hard part, and Makerloom does it. A new Shopify store starts with zero visitors and no reviews. Makerloom starts by publishing helpful pages that answer real searches, featuring your products.

No second store to run. Orders, messages, refunds and shipping stay in Etsy, in one place.

Your Etsy reviews keep working. Shoppers who tap through land on listings with your reviews and Etsy's buyer protection, which helps them buy from a shop they just discovered.

Lower cost. Starter is $19 a month with no card fees on top, and it writes 8 posts a month.

Where Shopify differs

Shopify lets you sell off Etsy with your own checkout, which avoids Etsy's fees on those sales. That pays off when your own site already has steady visitors who buy there. Until then, the cost is the plan, the apps and the time spent bringing shoppers.

Cost over a year

Makerloom Starter Shopify Basic (yearly)
Subscription $228 $348
Card fees on $5,000 of sales $0 (Etsy's fees apply on Etsy) About $160
Apps (email, reviews, Etsy sync) None needed Often $10 to $50 a month
Posts written for you 96 0

Using both

Some sellers already have a Shopify store. Makerloom can still help: its posts link to your Etsy listings, and your Shopify store and Makerloom site can link to each other. If you'd rather send post readers to Shopify, Makerloom isn't the right tool; it's built around Etsy.

What running each one takes

Shopify is a second business to run. You choose a theme, set up payments, shipping rates, taxes and policies, install apps for reviews, email and Etsy sync, and answer buyers in a new inbox. Every order placed there is yours to handle outside Etsy.

Makerloom adds no new inbox, no new checkout and no new orders. Buyers still order on Etsy. Your week is approving a few posts and glancing at which ones sent shoppers to your listings.

Who each one suits

You're... Better fit
Selling mostly on Etsy and want more shoppers Makerloom
Short on time each week Makerloom
Building a wholesale or high-volume brand with its own audience Shopify
Ready to handle payments, refunds and support yourself Shopify

Common questions

Is Shopify better for SEO than Etsy?

Shopify gives you pages you control, which is good for SEO, but you still need content that answers searches. Makerloom gives you that content automatically.

Should I move from Etsy to Shopify?

Only if you're ready to bring every buyer yourself. Many sellers keep Etsy as the shop and build their own traffic first.

Does Makerloom work with Shopify?

Makerloom reads products from Etsy, not Shopify.

Sources

  • shopify.com/pricing, checked November 2026

Get shoppers to your Etsy listings from Google and AI answers.

Try Makerloom free

Prices and features of other products were checked on their own websites on the date above and can change. Makerloom isn't affiliated with the companies mentioned on this page.

More compare