Makerloom vs Squarespace for Etsy sellers

Updated November 2026

Short answer: Squarespace is a beautiful, general-purpose website builder, from $19 a month billed yearly ($25 monthly) on Basic, with a 2% fee on store sales at that level. You design it, add products, and write every page and post yourself. Makerloom is built for Etsy sellers: it syncs your Etsy listings, writes posts that answer what shoppers search, and links every product to Etsy. If the goal is more shoppers for your Etsy shop, Makerloom does the part Squarespace leaves to you.

At a glance

Makerloom Squarespace
Price Free to start, then $19, $39 or $79 a month Basic $19 a month yearly or $25 monthly; Core $29 or $39
Store transaction fee None 2% on Basic, 0% on Core and up
Etsy products Synced automatically Added by hand or imported
Writes posts for you Yes, 8 to 40 a month No
Built to rank for shopper questions Yes Depends on what you write
AI visits shown Yes No
Design control Clean theme with your logo and color Full design control
Checkout Etsy Squarespace Commerce

Where Makerloom is stronger

Content that brings visitors, made for you. A beautiful site without new pages rarely brings new shoppers. Makerloom publishes on a steady schedule, each post targeting a search a real buyer types.

Your Etsy shop stays the store. No duplicate product catalog to keep in sync, no second checkout to manage.

Setup in minutes. Connect Etsy, write two sentences about your shop, approve your first post.

Results you can read. Visits from Google, ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini, and clicks from each post to Etsy.

Where Squarespace differs

Squarespace gives you full control of layout and design and can run its own store. It's a good fit for a portfolio or a brand site where you're happy to write and maintain everything.

Cost over a year

Makerloom Starter Squarespace Basic (yearly)
Subscription $228 $228
Posts written 96 0
Hours designing and writing About 1 to set up Many

Using both

If you already have a Squarespace site, you can keep it as your brand home and add Makerloom on its own address for posts that send shoppers to Etsy, linking the two. On Studio, Makerloom can sit on a subdomain like shop.yourbrand.com.

What a seller's week looks like with each

With Squarespace, the first weekend goes on picking a template, writing pages and adding products. After that the site stays as it is unless you write new pages yourself. Many handmade sellers end up with a beautiful site that gets few visitors, because the time goes into making and shipping.

With Makerloom, setup is connecting Etsy and writing two sentences about your shop. After that, drafts arrive on the schedule you set, each one aimed at something a shopper searches. A typical week is a few minutes reading and approving.

Where new visitors come from

Visitors come from With Squarespace With Makerloom
Google searches for questions Blog posts you write Posts written from your listings, which you approve
AI answers (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini) Pages you write The same posts, with a short answer first so they're easy to quote
Your email list Squarespace Email Campaigns (paid add-on) Signup on every page, export to any email tool
Etsy A link to your shop Every product links to its own Etsy listing

Selling on Squarespace vs selling on Etsy

Selling on your own Squarespace store moves the sale off Etsy, so you handle payments, refunds and buyer questions there, and new visitors don't see your Etsy reviews. Makerloom keeps the sale on Etsy, where buyers already trust the checkout and your review count travels with every listing. For a shop that's still building an audience, that trust is often what turns a first-time visitor into a buyer.

Moving from Squarespace

You can keep Squarespace as your brand page and link it to your Makerloom site, or point your domain at Makerloom on Studio. See Use your own domain.

Common questions

Can Squarespace sync with Etsy?

Squarespace has had Etsy product import options, but they don't keep your products in sync the way a direct connection does. Check Squarespace's current help pages.

Which is better for SEO?

Both produce clean pages. What makes a site rank is helpful content published consistently, which Makerloom does for you.

Sources

  • squarespace.com/pricing, checked November 2026

Get shoppers to your Etsy listings from Google and AI answers.

Try Makerloom free

Prices and features of other products were checked on their own websites on the date above and can change. Makerloom isn't affiliated with the companies mentioned on this page.

More compare